Tattoos, Fair Use, and the Intrinsic Test: Ninth Circuit Affirms Jury Verdict in Sedlik v. Von Drachenberg
In Sedlik v. Von Drachenberg, et al., No. 24-3367 (9th Cir. 2026), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently upheld a jury’s decision that Kat Von D (Katherine Von Drachenberg) did not infringe photographer Jeffrey Sedlik’s copyright in his well-known Miles Davis photograph. The court’s published opinion and an unpublished memorandum highlight the deference given to juries in copyright cases and reveal some judges’ concerns about the Ninth Circuit’s method for determining substantial similarity.
Jeffrey Sedlik owns the copyright to a well-known 1989 photograph of Miles Davis. In 2017, Kat Von D created a Miles Davis tattoo for a friend, using Sedlik’s photo as a reference. She traced the image to make a stencil, completed the tattoo primarily with freehand shading, produced a sketch, and shared images of the process and finished tattoo on social media. Sedlik filed a copyright infringement lawsuit, alleging that the tattoo, sketch, and related social media posts infringed on his photograph. The case proceeded to trial, where the jury considered substantial similarity and fair use under Ninth Circuit law.
The jury found that the tattoo, preparatory sketch, and most social media posts were not substantially similar to Sedlik’s photograph under the intrinsic test, which considers whether an ordinary observer would find the works similar in their “total concept and feel.” The four “Process Images” posted on social media that reproduced the photograph, the jury found the use to be fair.
In a published per curiam opinion, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the verdict. The court held that denial of summary judgment is not reviewable after a full jury trial and that Sedlik did not demonstrate the jury’s verdict was unsupported by the evidence. The court emphasized that the intrinsic test is within the jury’s domain and declined to overturn the finding of no substantial similarity.
In a separate unpublished memorandum, the court rejected Sedlik’s remaining challenges, including objections to the jury’s fair use verdict, instructions, and evidentiary rulings. The panel noted procedural errors that prevented post-verdict relief and found sufficient evidence supported the jury’s fair use determination for the Process Images.
Of import were the two concurring opinions that followed the decision.
Judge Johnstone’s concurrence, joined by Judge Wardlaw, argued that the Ninth Circuit’s copyright doctrine has “drifted from its own origins” and lost meaningful legal content. He criticized the intrinsic test as lacking standards, allowing juries to reach verdicts without clear guidance from copyright law. Judge Johnstone also noted that the tattoo was marketed as “100% exactly the same” as the photograph and suggested that, under a properly filtered analysis of protectable expression, the tattoo would likely infringe.
Judge Wardlaw’s concurrence, joined by Judge Johnstone, went further by suggesting the intrinsic test has fundamental flaws and should be reconsidered. Judge Wardlaw warned that a purely subjective inquiry into “total concept and feel” risks undermining copyright protection by failing to distinguish protected expression from unprotectable ideas, leaving creative works vulnerable to “clever thieves.”
Please join us on Monday, January 12, 2026, at noon for a discussion of the decision made by the Ninth Circuit.
Jonathan Gutierrez, associate at SoCal IP, will lead the discussion.
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.